Friday, Nov 20, 2026
📍 Lahore | ☀️ 17°C | AQI: 5 (Very Poor)

Tradition on trial

Amir Noorani

 Here’s a story about a roast. A woman cuts the ends off the meat before placing it in the oven.  And why does she do that?  Well, that’s how her mother taught her. When her daughter asks why she does that, she has no idea, so she calls her mom, who doesn’t know why either, and calls her grandma, who tells her that she didn’t have a big enough pan.

I love this story, and that saddens me a little because I have plenty of little pans of my own, and I know you may do too. Interestingly, half the things we treat as sacrosanct are somebody’s little pan. And we never once thought to ask our grandma, did we?

Why don’t we ask?  Well, when it comes to tradition, the oldest form of protection you have is time. If you used the word “generations” in your debate, the room would capitulate every time. We assume that if something has stood the test of time, then it must be right and that our ancestors knew better than we do or ever did, which usually comes from people who haven’t read what our ancestors thought about anything, for that matter.

Of course, I’m not going to go on a tirade about how tradition isn’t always beneficial. Some traditions are distilled knowledge of how to keep alive. How to stay together.  How to stay sane.  It took years to acquire this knowledge and learn from others’ mistakes; we no longer have the luxury to make our own. That’s why every culture on earth came up with the concept of eating together, grieving together, and celebrating at the exact moment we were about to give up on winter. If a tradition still provides for a human need, then yes, it’s impressive that it has lasted so long, and you probably want to know what it does for you before dismantling it.

Hang on, though. Look at what is actually doing the heavy lifting here.  It wasn’t the ‘age’ of the tradition but its ‘mileage’ and whether it was still addressing a human need. Yes, old things have had time to prove themselves. But surviving isn’t proof. Plenty of pernicious things survived too, for exactly as long as people tolerated them.  Dowry survived centuries of approval, and slavery survived even longer. Things survive for many reasons, not only because they work, but also because whoever holds the microphone likes them and because the people paying haven’t had a say in it.

What amuses me, though, is that we allow traditions to change constantly while professing that nothing has changed. For example, a “traditional” wedding requires an event planner, a drone, and a loan. Something your grandma, whom you are trying to honour by emulating, would never understand. But each generation is told that it’s always been done this way. Which brings us to a discomfiting question. If a tradition can change to fit our needs, why can’t we change them to be fair?

Well, you already know the answer to that question because it depends on who is asking. Which leads us to the real problem.  It’s never been about old and new; it’s always been about the group and the individual within it. Tradition benefits the group, but its costs are borne by individuals. The group gets to have the wedding, but the bride takes on the debt. Everyone thinks it’s a great idea that the son should take over the family business. Nobody ever asked the son. 

Maybe you’ve been the son, the bride, or simply the one left holding it all together.  I believe most of us have been on both sides of this issue at some point. We’ve suffered under a tradition and handed one down. So, I reckon, we sit down, think about these questions, and be honest with ourselves, since nobody is grading us. What tradition do we stand by, and are we paying for it? Would the person who started it be proud of us, or would they laugh like the grandma? And most importantly, if this tradition was brand new and we had no knowledge of it, would we participate?  If the answer is no, then perhaps we aren’t protecting wisdom; we are merely protecting a habit we are too fainthearted to let go of.

Before you throw a sledgehammer at me, I want to be clear: I’m not saying to tear everything down. There is a sensible old principle called Chesterton’s fence: you shouldn’t knock down a fence if you don’t know why it’s there. Seems pretty obvious that you shouldn’t knock down a fence if you don’t know why it’s there. Seems axiomatic that you shouldn’t destroy something you have never bothered to understand. 

But the principle requires you to actually find out, and finding out can go either way. Sometimes you will see a fence and realise it’s keeping someone from falling off a cliff. Other times, you will realise that it’s been doing nothing for the past eighty years except keeping two neighbours apart, who forgot why it’s there and why it was built in the first place.

So that’s where I stand, for whatever it’s worth. Tradition mustn’t be venerated simply for having lasted that long any more than a man should be respected simply for being loud. It deserves something better than veneration: it deserves attention. Find out what a practice was created to do and whether it still does that. Find out who it helps, who pays for it, and whether the one paying ever agreed to it in the first place.  Hold on to the ones that benefit your people and send the rest off with dignity.

If that sounds too strong, here is a little secret. Every tradition you revere today was once a scandal.  Something someone brave or stubborn did against the tradition that came before it. Our ancestors weren’t curators; they were editors. The most traditional thing you and I can do is follow suit: keep what helps people thrive, cut what no longer does, and trust our grandchildren to judge us exactly the way we have judged the past.

If anyone disagrees, tell them about the pan.

Share This Article
Amir has written for numerous online and offline publications on governance, politics, youth development, civil rights, arts and culture, and environmental justice. Whether crafting brand manifestos or social commentary, Amir brings clarity, creativity, and purpose to every piece he writes.
Leave a comment

Don’t Miss Our Latest Updates