Friendship was something that implied proximity. Friends were from the same street, same class, same tea stall after tuitions. This is how the majority of friendships form in Pakistan even now. They grow up in neighbourhoods where the doors remain open, and names are called out from balconies. Universities maintain the same proximity into adulthood through years of studying, eating lunch, and completing assignments together, making the relationship feel permanent. And then, suddenly, everyone disappears.
Migration is now an average part of young Pakistanis’ lives. A few friends go abroad to pursue further studies. Others work in Karachi, Lahore, or Islamabad, which are geographically close but, in reality, far away given the time spent on the road, hours worked, and rent paid. Many young women move into new households as a result of marriage, some of which may be in new cities, and their old friendships are put to a test against new domestic obligations. Even those who stay behind find that their friends have not. Within a few years, a weekly meeting group can be divided among three continents and five time zones.
This scattering poses an implicit question. Is intimacy possible without the continuity of shared space in one’s daily existence? The simple response would be that technology provides the solution. Video conversations, voice messages, and group chats become sufficient surrogates for physical closeness. The truth is far from simple. Technology facilitates the survival of friendship, but it fails to preserve it in its original state. It alters the demands placed on friendship.
Take the voice message, now the dominant mode of interaction among young people in Pakistan scattered around the world. The former doesn’t entail the two parties being free simultaneously as in a telephone conversation. The latter isn’t limited to the written word and includes inflection and pauses. One friend in Toronto can record a three-minute message while cooking dinner; another friend in Lahore can listen to it hours later during his commute. This asymmetry fits well with lives that are no longer coordinated by schedule or even time zones.
Group chats are similar in function, but their value lies more in the accumulation of conversations than in individual messages. A meme posted in the dead of night, a photograph of an old classroom, a joke that requires five years of experience to understand. Such conversations serve little purpose other than reminding group members that someone remembers them and thinks of them from time to time. In these cases, friends are sustained not through deep conversations but through frequent messages, and it is effective for some period of time.
When there is a visit, it comes with its own pressure. The visit of a friend to his or her hometown after several months, or a reunion organized during someone’s wedding celebration turns out to be something that the group has been working on for a long time. It goes without saying that everyone is eager to recreate those days when everything was easier and didn’t require too much effort. Usually, it is successful for a brief moment of time, but then the visit makes one realize how different it was.
The glue for these friendships is not the app or even the visits but rather the shared history. When young Pakistanis have been friends since they met in school, there will be an archive of jokes and memories that the newer friendships will not share. The archive will not require frequent updates to remain useful. It works as a kind of foundation that can always be revisited, even after months of silence. Even if a friend has not been talked to for eight months, he will still be regarded as close by virtue of the depth of the shared history.
But a friendship cannot endure forever in history. Even the greatest common bond can be transformed into a memory instead of a relationship if no one makes a conscious effort to maintain it. This is the actual possibility of geographic scattering. Friends are no longer those you speak with about here, but people you recall from yesterday and yesterday. The friendship lives on in the mind, among the warm sentiments of old photographs, not as an active link. This is what many young Pakistanis feel, they love the country but are not actively involved in being friends with it.
There is also an emotional price attached to Pakistani society that comes along with its structure. Personal responsibilities, particularly those of women post-marriage, often consume the necessary time and effort needed to cultivate friendships outside of the family unit. Long working hours in places such as Karachi leave no time for calls or messages that help to maintain long-distance friendships. Those who suffer the most from the scattering process are the ones who have the least ability to combat it.
Out of it all comes a new kind of friendship, an old one that doesn’t look like the friendship of childhood with its constant, corporeal presence. This is an updated version that is intermittent rather than continuous. It’s about voice notes rather than conversation, visits rather than regular meetings and shared history rather than shared present. It demands attention rather than proximity. Friends have to make a conscious decision, over and over again, to maintain contact rather than letting things fall into place.
This change is not inherently negative, even if it is perceived as such. This is due to changes in youth mobility in Pakistan. There are fewer people who spend the rest of their adult lives in the city in which they grow up, and there are fewer friendship circles that manage to stay together into their twenties and thirties. The new system of friendship that replaces the old one is no worse, but just different, and youth is figuring out how to maintain it.


